Can text messages be used in court, and how are they authenticated?

Yes. Text messages are used as evidence in divorce, custody, employment, housing and harassment cases every day. The side that offers them usually has to show they are what they claim to be, typically who sent them and when, and the other side can ask for the rest of the conversation if parts were left out. The rules differ between countries and states, so your lawyer decides how to present them; here is what usually matters, and how to prepare a complete record on a Mac.

Updated

Download for Mac — free

macOS 14 or later · the Record layout is part of Pro, $19.99 once

What courts look for

In US federal courts, for example, Rule 901 of the Federal Rules of Evidence asks for evidence “sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.” Usually that is the testimony of someone who took part in the conversation, backed by the details above. When authenticity is seriously disputed, a court may want the phone itself examined by a forensic examiner.

Why screenshots get challenged

A screenshot shows the time only where Messages chooses to, cuts a long conversation into pieces, and hides the sender's number behind a contact name you can rename. Fake chat screenshots are easy to make, and judges and opposing lawyers know it. Screenshots are still used, especially for a few messages, but a complete, numbered record of the whole conversation leaves far less room for doubt.

How to prepare a complete record from your Mac

  1. Get the messages onto your Mac: turn on Messages in iCloud on the iPhone and on the Mac (Messages › Settings › iMessage › Enable Messages in iCloud) and let it sync.
  2. Open Textbound and allow Full Disk Access once, so it can read the Messages history. It reads it without changing anything.
  3. Pick the conversation and the dates your lawyer asked for. If the case is in another time zone, choose it first in Textbound › Settings › Times shown in.
  4. Export with the Record layout. Each message gets a row with its date, its time to the second, the sender and the service (iMessage, SMS or RCS). Read times, reactions, edits with their earlier versions and unsent messages are shown too. Every page says “Page x of y”, and the cover lists every participant with their number or email.
  5. When the export finishes, Textbound shows two codes; keep both. The fingerprint identifies the messages, and it is printed in the PDF too. The SHA-256 identifies the file: it changes if even one byte of the file changes.
  6. Keep the original messages and the phone. Don't delete the conversation after exporting.

How someone can check the record

Every attachment in a Record PDF has its SHA-256 next to it and in an appendix, and the whole export has a fingerprint calculated from every message, time and file. On the Mac the export was made on, File › Verify an Export… (⇧⌘V) makes the export again from Messages and compares every page: it says whether the PDF was changed after export, or whether the messages on the Mac no longer match. Anyone else can check that a file is the one you sent by its SHA-256 (on a Mac, in Terminal: shasum -a 256 followed by the file).

What Textbound doesn't do

Your messages stay with you while you prepare all this: Textbound reads them on your Mac, has no account, and sends nothing anywhere.

Questions

Are screenshots of text messages enough for court?

Sometimes, for a few messages that nobody disputes. When the other side contests them, gaps in the times, missing context and the ease of faking a screenshot work against you. A complete printout of the conversation, with every time, every sender and page numbers, gives them much less to argue about.

How do you prove who sent a text message?

Usually with the phone number or email address behind the message and testimony that it belongs to that person; the content and the context help. The Record cover lists every participant with their number or email, and every row shows its sender.

Do I need to keep my phone?

Yes. Keep the phone and the original conversation even after you have a printout: a court or the other side may ask to see them, and an examiner may need the device.

Can deleted text messages be used as evidence?

Sometimes a forensic examiner can recover them from a device or a backup. Textbound can't: it shows only what is still in Messages on your Mac.

Can the other side check that my PDF wasn't edited?

They can check that the file is the one you sent by its SHA-256. The full check, Verify, runs on the Mac the export was made on: it compares every page with the messages still there.

Prepare the record on your Mac

Related: print text messages for court · see the exact time of a message · print text messages from an iPhone